Joan Lindh's BHR Revision to THR by Mr. McMinn 2010

Published on Mar 27, 2013

Joan Lindh had a Birmingham Hip Resurfacing (BHR) operation in 1999. Around ten years later, she underwent revision surgery in which her BHR was revised to a Total Hip Replacement (THR). Joan maintains that the BHR gave her 'ten good years' and since the revision has gone back to leading a normal life.

You can read Joan's story on our website here:

Joan is an active housewife from Surrey who enjoys golf, tennis and cycling. She struggled for seven years with hip arthritis but, following a BHR with Mr McMinn in 1999, got back to a highly active, happy lifestyle continuing to play the sports she loves.

Around 10 years post op, she began experiencing a dull ache in her groin and travelled back to Birmingham for blood tests with the McMinn clinical team. They soon discovered Joan had a metal allergy which unfortunately caused a swelling (or 'pseudotumour') around her hip and some acetabular bone damage. Joan's body had reacted badly to the normal amounts of metal ions released by her BHR. And, though the implant had not worn abnormally, the problem would require revision surgery to correct.

In January 2010 Joan had her BHR revised to a total hip replacement (THR). She was delighted to get back to normal life quickly and recalls, "I was in hospital for five days. The wound healed fine. The day after coming home I cooked supper using one crutch around the kitchen. The following day I went to the supermarket."

Aware of the sensational press stories surrounding Metal-on-Metal (MoM) implants, Joan took a positive outlook on her situation. "I've had 10 good years of my life restored to me," she says. "Ten years ago, had I known that I would need a revision at this stage I would not have changed a thing. I'd have gone ahead with the resurfacing operation."

The press have reported severe metal reactions in MoM patients, particularly those fitted with a failed ASR hip resurfacing. These cases must be put into perspective, however. For the most part, pseudotumours and metal reactions are very uncommon in patients with a well-implanted BHR. In Mr McMinn's series of 3,205 BHRs for example, only 11 patients (0.3%) have suffered MoM reactions and all are doing well following their revision surgery.

Joan, for instance, even managed to fit in some travelling following her THR. "We went to New York six weeks after the operation," she says. "We walked for miles and used the subway a lot. I just didn't give it a second thought - in fact I was walking better than my husband and my daughter! Two months after the operation I was back to life as usual."

Since her revision surgery, Joan has managed to get back to playing regular golf, commenting, "I feel very confident with my new hip; very comfortable. I've walked for miles and I haven't had any feeling of insecurity with it at all. It's just very easy."

More on this article:
For a list of FAQs on Pseudotumours, please click here:

For a detailed metal ion Q&A from the McMinn Research Team, please click here:

For more information on Derek McMinn and the Birmingham Hip Resurfacing please visit

Developed in conjunction with Joomla extensions.


Visitors Counter

Highest 03-01-2017 : 1042
Statistik created: 2017-03-28T22:11:39+00:00

Web design by Patricia Walter Copyright Surface Hippy 12/11/2005
Mission Statement - Surface Hippy is a patient to patient guide to hip resurfacing.
It does not provide medical advice. It is designed to support, not to replace, the relationship between patient and clinician.
Advertising - Revenue from this site is derived from commercial advertising and individual donations.
Any advertisement is distinguished by the word "advertisement"
Privacy - Surface Hippy does not share email addresses or personal information with any group or organization.
Content - Surface Hippy is not controlled or influenced by any medical companies, doctors or hospitals.
All content is controlled by Patricia Walter - Joint Health Sites LLC

Go to top